Tag Archives: Carrie Fisher

Star Wars IX : The Rise Of Skywalker (2019) Movie Review By Philip Henry

The Rise Of Skywalker Review

Director: JJ Abrams
Screenwriters: JJ Arbrams, Chris Terrio
Stars: Daisy Ridley, Adam Driver, Oscar Isaac, John Boyega, Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, Richard E Grant

JJ Abrams is tasked with the unenviable task of trying to bring the most beloved franchise in history to a conclusion and satisfy the millions of fans worldwide. Of course that’s impossible. You only have to look at individual ‘rank the Star Wars films in order of greatness’ lists online to see that everyone has very different ideas about what makes a great Star Wars film. From what I can glean, how you rate these films has a lot to do with which film introduced you to the magic of George Lucas’s galaxy. Believe it or not, there is great love for even the worst of the prequels out there from people who walked into a movie theatre for the first time in 1999 and never wanted to leave.

So this film isn’t going to please everyone. That’s a given. But I saw it at the midnight screening with a bunch of hardcore fans and heard nothing but excited praise as I left the cinema. We all loved it. And that ranged from golden oldies to kids who should’ve been in bed, but would probably always thank their parents for making this exception.

I’m not going to get into the specifics of the story, because I don’t want to spoil anything for genuine fans who are excited for this movie, so I’ll only touch on things that the trailer has already revealed and try to address some of the dumber criticisms I’ve seen in the negative reviews.

So the Emperor is back, or to be more precise, he never really went away, and it’s up to our heroes to end the Sith leader once and for all before his latest deadly plan for mass destruction comes to fruition. This film hits the ground running and barely pauses for breath the whole way through. It’s a race against time and there’s a lot of ground to cover.

In short, a lot of stuff happens during this film and it’s a lot to unpack after you’ve seen it. If I have one criticism it’s that this film tries to cram two films into one, but I believe, for the most part, it succeeds in doing just that. The reason it needs to do this is the old elephant in the room… The Last Jedi.

TLJ has its supporters, but I’m firmly in the camp that thinks it’s a complete disaster – a square peg trying to fit into a round hole – and Rian Johnson’s refusal to pick up the story strands laid down by Lawrence Kasdan and JJ Abrams in The Force Awakens is the reason TRoS has to spend a certain amount of time setting things straight again.

JJ and Co. are towing the party line at the minute while doing press saying what a ‘great job’ Rian Johnson did, but you only have to look at how much backtracking there is in this movie to see that Mr Abrams was not happy with the direction of Episode VIII. In fact I’d go so far as to say there are several occasions in TRoS where JJ raises a very definite middle finger to some of the terrible ideas Rian Johnson had.

So if it seems rushed in places, blame Johnson for not running with ideas like The Knights of Ren. Kylo’s hand-picked henchmen are in this movie, but I can’t help thinking if they’d been established in Ep8 like they were supposed to be, their presence would have much more weight. We also see Rey training in the trailer – this is something else that should’ve happened in Ep8 if Johnson hadn’t made some awful decisions about changing Luke’s character.

The Last Jedi really does stick out like the haemorrhoid I always believed it to be after seeing TRoS. It’s just terribly written. You notice the great friendship and banter between Finn and Poe in Ep7, and then it disappears in Ep8, and then it’s back in Ep9. These inconsistencies are what really bother me about Rian Johnson’s attempt at a SW film. The defence I always hear is that he ‘tried something different’. Where? All he did was insert misjudged humour, ignore the personalities of already established characters, and craft a film that spends two and a half hours treading water; there’s no character arcs and the story barely moves – everyone’s in exactly the same place at the end of the movie as they are at the beginning. It’s a pointless film, and after seeing Ep9 I think it’s safe to say that if you watch the whole saga now, and skip Ep8, you haven’t missed anything important to the story. I will eternally love Ep9 for giving me that.

Ep9 takes more chances and has more twists than TLJ ever did. There are some genuine jaw-dropping moments that side-swiped me and the rest of the hardcore fans I was watching with. There are of course moments of fan-service that hail back to the other films, but I didn’t mind these at all, and given the looks of glee on the faces all around me, no one else did either. It’s fan service, but it’s fan service done properly.

I’ve read some of the spoiler-heavy negative reviews out there and I disagree with most of them. People who say this or that doesn’t make sense, either don’t know Star Wars very well, or they just know their YouTube video will get more clicks if they say something nasty. It’s a sad state of affairs that SW bashing has become the norm online. I could answer every single criticism I’ve seen online and tear their argument to shreds, so I don’t take any of these negative reviews too seriously. They’re obviously written by very casual viewers (no, I’m not even going to call them fans). I hope the box office will tell a different story because this is a thrill-packed ending to the Skywalker saga and will please any real fans of this galaxy far, far away…

If The Last Jedi destroyed your faith in Star Wars, come back and see The Rise of Skywalker and give it a chance to make you a believer again. Our heroes have all got their personalities back and the worst decisions of TLJ are backtracked and glossed over. It makes TLJ a pretty inconsequential film now.

Will it please everyone? Of course not, but I for one I’m glad this film exists and I think Abrams and Terrio did an excellent job pulling this sequel trilogy back from the brink. While not every plot strand or character arc is resolved to satisfaction, they concentrate on the main thrust of the story and follow it through brilliantly. As a writer myself, I know there just isn’t enough time to walk us through everyone’s epilogue – there’s just too many characters. You would end up with the 15 endings everyone complained about in Return of the King.

This is Star Wars back to how it should be; fun, exciting and full of drama and emotion. The final battle is on a scale never seen before and the twists and turns will slap a smile on the face of real fans that it will be hard to shift. Given the drag factor of TLJ, it’s as good an ending as we could’ve hoped for, and one I will rewatch many more times.

The force will be with me, always.

Star Wars: The Last Jedi (2017) Movie Review by John Walsh


Director: Rian Johnson
Writers: Rian Johnson, George Lucas (based on characters created by)
Stars: Mark Hamill, Carrie Fisher, Daisy Ridley, Adam Driver, John Boyega, Oscar Isaac, Andy Serkis, Domhnall Gleeson

Well it has to be said, its been two extremely quick years following the release of ‘The Force Awakens’ and now Rian Johnson’s take on the Star Wars saga is out in theatres. It would be fair to say that not everyone is a overly enamoured with his vision. There has been a very vocal minority of Star Wars fandom that have taken to aggressively bashing it; even going as far as creating bots to negatively impact the Rotten Tomatoes viewer score.

This doesn’t mean that every detractor of the film is doing this or is wrong to be airing their grievances. They aren’t. Films are a highly subjective matter at the best of times. Now, combine that with a much beloved franchise and characters that have been a part of pop culture for nigh on 40 years and you’ve got yourself a recipe for some heated disagreements.

But enough of that hysteria. What did I make of it all? Well, if you’ve been listening to our podcasts then we did actually do a review last week but laying out your thoughts mere hours after leaving the cinema can make for tricky business. Things can be missed. Hence why I’m doing a written version after another viewing in an attempt to do a more ‘in depth’ review.

First of all, I’ve been a Star Wars fan for as long as I can remember. I recall playing with a Sand People figure when I was about four or five years of age and being absolutely fascinated with that galaxy far, far away. My credentials in that department are undeniable, and as a complete nobody, I can’t be accused of being a Disney shill. I absolutely loved this film. It’s not good enough to trouble the original three but it’s a damn good film and I’m genuinely perplexed at the vitriol coming from some quarters.

It begs the question. Just what were people expecting? A three and half hour long film that answered every single theory just as they’d painstakingly thought out?

Rian Johnson has a reputation for going dark, for his excellent writing ability and for just being a great director period. He’s also been a Star Wars fan from the age of four. What better credentials could you ask for? And what he’s given us is a fabulously entertaining film, that develops the newer characters well, offers a satisfying progression for the older characters, but more importantly expands and shakes up a mythology and galaxy that quite frankly had become static and in danger of repeating itself ad infinitum.

He tied up the two major loose ends JJ left from ‘The Force Awakens’ and did it well. Was it exactly what I wanted? Nope. Did I enjoy the direction he took? Yup. Rey’s parents? Yeah, they were unimportant nobodies. She wasn’t a Skywalker but instead a naturally gifted random. Fair enough. Snoke? He wasn’t Darth Plagueis. He was just some bushy eyed, deformed looking weirdo with a frankly incredible connection to the force, that had a fetish for gold and was cut down in spectacular fashion.

Luke Skywalker is by far my favourite Star Wars character. His arc seems to be causing the biggest amount of anguish amongst the films detractors. Again, Rian Johnson did not go down the path I personally would have liked to have seen come to fruition. He didn’t cut down the Knights of Ren in an epic lightsaber battle, didn’t slap down Kylo and he didn’t even leave that bloody island. But man, did I enjoy Luke in this film. The way he takes his nephew to school at the end, playing on his clear penchant for impulsiveness was a joy to behold.

The sight of him walking out to face the might of the First Order was a standout moment. Everything about it was perfect. From ‘The Spark’ theme (Williams best in this film) to the visuals, it had my personal favourite wide shot in the film too.

Mark Hamill is utterly brilliant in ‘The Last Jedi’. It’s arguably his best performance in the character of Luke. Hell, it’s arguably one of his best live action performances period. He’s been through some shit and it’s changed his character in the thirty year gap. He’s experienced unimaginable hardship, loss and learned some incredibly cool force abilities. He’s a tad grouchy and he’s taken to drinking green milk from the udder of a hideous alien. He also lost some weight and looks fantastic for it.

Princess Leia is handled very well too. The late Carrie Fisher was much improved here, giving a very good showing, following her practically mute role in ‘The Force Awakens’. The infamous space scene wasn’t as bad as some have made out. I thought the scoring and visuals were on point during it and it finally showed us Leia using the force. What’s not to like? I was also incredibly pleased to see her have a moment with Luke. It would have been criminal for either of those two to go out without sharing a scene together. It was a genuine lump in the throat moment.

Visually, I thought the film was stunning. It’s the most stylish to date and some of the action, aided by lovely wide shots, was jaw dropping. The opening shot where the camera rushes down was exhilarating, the Canto Bight stuff popped despite being superfluous, the scene when General Holdo (Laura Dern) sends the Resistance cruiser zooming through Snoke’s Supremacy was ridiculously cool and that lightsaber battle in the throne room is up there for me. There was a plethora of visually incredible moments in this film and sadly I can’t possibly list them all which is annoying.

Speaking of Canto Bight. Finn and Rose’s side plot was unnecessary, disrupted the pacing, was off in terms of tone and felt like a rather convoluted way to setup the showdown on Crait. Benicio Del Toro’s character was poor and don’t even get me started on the druggy stutter. It felt superfluous to the main plot and conjured up memories of the prequels whilst also featuring some real corny dialogue. That along with some poorly worked comedic moments and the slightly underwhelming walkers at the end was the only real let down for me.

In terms of Rey and Kylo. I actually loved the whole dynamic of their relationship in this one. The force ‘FaceTiming’ as I called it wasn’t that off putting, was explained well and again opened up new possibilities. Rey is obviously struggling to find her role in things, trying to coax Luke into training her whilst Kylo is really on the end of a prolonged bout of bullying at the hands of Snoke and equally questioning his role. Which is why I was delighted when he ended him. It was deserved and Kylo is fast becoming my favourite of the newer characters.

Adam Driver is a brilliant actor and he’s really showing up Hayden Christiansen in the how to play a conflicted character stakes. I see now why JJ hand picked him for this role. By the end, it’s pretty clear that he’s went full big bad however which is a shame because even now I want him redeemed. He’s clearly the last thread of Skywalker heritage in this saga that can realistically continue and for that reason alone I want him to survive. It’ll be very interesting to see where he goes from this.

Daisy Ridley has been criticised in some circles for her so called wooden delivery of certain lines. I must have been watching a different film though because I missed these completely. Perhaps I was too busy just enjoying the story and action instead of looking for reasons to throw the toys out the pram. She was absolutely fine for me and I felt they reigned in her ‘overpowered’ abilities, making her more vulnerable, particularly during the throne room sequences to appease the ‘Mary Sue’ brigade.

I can’t discuss this film without mentioning Poe and General Hux. Oscar Isaac is a talented actor and I’m delighted he was given a chunkier role. He learnt a valuable lesson in this and it looks like he’s taking control of the Resistance going forward. Hux was often used as comedic levity and for the most part it worked. His little smirk at Kylo upon leaving the throne room and general slyness was oddly enjoyable. Domhnall Gleeson owns the character.

Musically, John Williams returns to score this and it’s brilliance from the man as ever. There’s not many new themes in there but that’s probably because there’s not many new characters worthy of them. What he does do is reintroduce many classics to delightful effect. The Leia theme has a delicate moment in the space scene whilst Yoda’s adds an emotional edge to the return of that particular character. It just isn’t Star Wars without the great mans involvement.

Incidentally, the Yoda scene was absolutely fantastic. The puppet looked great and they nailed the mannerisms and the eccentric personality we all loved from the Original trilogy.

This is a divisive film and much of the hate appears to stem from two main issues. Firstly, predetermined fan theories not coming true, and secondly, the apparent callous way in which established mythology and characters have been dealt with. As I said earlier, I’m delighted that the mythology has been freshened up. This misconception that you must be from famous lineage to be a Jedi is just that. I think the older characters were handled competently. It’s all subjective though.

Overall. I think the positives more than outweigh the negatives in ‘The Last Jedi’. It’s not perfect by any means but it’s a brilliant addition to the Star Wars saga and opens up so many possibilities going forward. It’s added freshness to the franchise, Luke still very much has a role to play and the fate of the Resistance hangs on a knife edge. I look forward to Episode 9 now and Rian Johnson’s trilogy and I highly recommend this one to the majority of fans. Most will already have seen it mind, but if you haven’t, then what the hell are you waiting for?

Rating: 4.5/5