Director: Oliver Schmitz
Writers: Chris Marnewick (novel),  Brian Cox (adaptation)
Stars: Andrea Riseborough,  Steve Coogan,  Garion Dowds

“Shepherds and Butchers” unfolds as a poignant and startling film drama set against the backdrop of South Africa’s apartheid era, skillfully balancing sensitivity and brutality. The narrative revolves around the trial of a mentally broken young prison guard, Leon Labuschagne, accused of multiple murders of a football team of black players, facing the grim prospect of the death penalty.

The courtroom takes center stage throughout the movie, with flashbacks and intervals of Johan Webber (portrayed by Steve Coogan) cross-examining his own path and motivations for defending an accused individual seemingly guilty of a heinous crime. Webber’s focus is on Labuschagne’s mental state, shaped by his close proximity to death row inmates, providing a compelling exploration of the events leading to that fateful night.

The film is unapologetically graphic and harrowing, captivating audiences with an emotional rollercoaster that prompts sympathy for the accused’s journey from School Prefect to a courtroom facing charges of multiple murders within a few years.

Steve Coogan, known primarily for his comedic roles, takes on the role of Webber with commendable skill, transitioning from reluctance to determination as Labuschagne’s defense counsel. Coogan’s performance is a standout, showcasing his versatility as an actor beyond the comedic realm.

Garion Dowds, portraying the accused Leon Labuschagne, delivers a compelling performance that belies his limited acting credits. Dowds convincingly embodies the character’s cold remorse and acceptance of his impending fate, adding depth to the narrative.

Director Oliver Schmitz infuses the film with a palpable 1980s ambiance, providing a glimpse into the challenging times of South Africa’s history. The cinematography captures the beauty of the surroundings while balancing the shocking execution scenes with the psychological toll on the guards, notably Leon Labuschagne.

As the story reaches its climactic conclusion, “Shepherds and Butchers” defies conventional resolutions, leaving viewers with complex and mixed emotions reminiscent of films like “The Woodsman.” The verdict’s satisfaction is deliberately left to individual interpretation, ensuring a thought-provoking experience.

From start to finish, the film impresses with its direction, character development, and deliberate use of close-ups in the courtroom, allowing the audience to share the emotional journey. Highly recommended, “Shepherds and Butchers” stands as a compelling cinematic experience, with Coogan’s standout performance making it a must-watch that warrants revisiting in the near future.

Follow @StephenJohn76